'Chicago Med' Season 10 Episode 19 "The Stories We Tell Ourselves" Review

This episode of Chicago Med Season 10 Episode 19 opens not at the hospital, but at Dennis and Sharon Goodwin’s home. Sharon is getting ready to head out when Alex, Dennis’s daughter, shows up unexpectedly. It’s clear right away that Dennis wasn’t totally upfront about his life back home, because Alex has no idea he’s been living with Sharon. Sharon tries to be welcoming, but the surprise throws everyone off. Dennis explains that Alex came back earlier than planned, and it’s immediately awkward. Still, Sharon handles it with grace, setting the tone for what’s clearly going to be a complicated day.

Meanwhile back at the hospital, things start a little lighter. Crockett offers to buy Lenox a coffee, and there’s this playful, easy chemistry between them. But the mood shifts fast when Crockett asks if she’s heard from Naomi, the first-year resident he’s been mentoring. Naomi missed multiple simulation sessions, something you really can’t afford to do when you’re trying to make it in cardiothoracic surgery. Crockett tries to cut Naomi some slack, saying first-year residents are under a lot of pressure, but Lenox knows better than to make excuses. In medicine, first impressions stick.

While that’s happening, Sharon dives into tense hospital negotiations with Maggie Coleman and the nurses’ union. The hospital offers a 4% raise and proposes a 1:5 nurse-patient ratio, but the nurses are holding firm on demanding a 1:4 ratio for patient safety. Sharon suggests a one-week extension to avoid an immediate strike. Both sides agree for now, but you can feel the tension buzzing under the surface, trust is already shaky, and it’s only getting worse.

Back in the ED, the team gets hit with a tough trauma case. Clarissa, a 13-year-old girl, has been hit by an emergency vehicle driven by EMT’s. She’s in bad shape, but what makes it even worse is that she has primary sclerosing cholangitis, a liver disease that severely complicates her chances. Without a liver transplant, she won’t survive. Matt Sutton, Hene’s partner and the EMT that was driving, offers to donate part of his liver. His wife Samantha is understandably scared, worried about the risks, the impact on their family, their financial stability, but Matt is determined. Dr. Charles steps in to evaluate him and clears him for donation, saying Matt’s doing this for the right reasons.

While that’s unfolding, young Max is facing his own heartbreaking reality. After being abandoned by his mother, he’s being placed with a foster family, the Andersons. Max clings to a fantasy that his mom is a superhero on a secret mission. Dr. Abrams and Dr. Frost try to help him process the truth gently. Eventually, Dr. Charles steps in and talks Max through it with a lot of care, making sure he feels safe even if the truth is painful.

While all that’s going on, Sharon meets Alex for lunch at the hospital. Dennis isn’t able to join them because of a patient emergency, but the lunch actually becomes a real turning point. Sharon opens up about her own family, her kids David, Michael, and Tara, and her past marriage to Bert, who now lives in a nursing home. Alex admits she’s scared of moving forward with her life milestones, like marriage or motherhood, without her mother there to see it. Sharon shares how she lost her own mother young too and reassures Alex that even though grief stays with you, so do the people you lose. It’s a raw but genuinely connecting moment between them.

Back in surgery, Clarissa’s transplant seems to be going well,  until Matt suffers a hypertensive crisis on the table. It’s a tense few minutes where everyone fears the worst, but after a nerve-wracking wait, Matt wakes up. He’s responsive and showing good signs. Dr. Archer orders an MRI to be cautious, but things are looking positive, and Samantha is overwhelmed with relief.

Meanwhile, Maggie Lockwood finds out that the hospital had secretly secured replacement nurses even before agreeing to the extension. Maggie feels completely blindsided, especially after she personally vouched for Sharon during negotiations. Sharon insists that the hospital is only trying to plan for backup in case there is a strike, but Maggie’s hurt. The trust between them is badly shaken, and you can tell this isn’t going to heal easily.

Elsewhere, Hannah Asher and her sister Lizzie share a heavy conversation. Hannah offers to be Lizzie’s surrogate, wanting to help her sister have a child. Lizzie worries that Hannah is sacrificing her own future without realizing it. Hannah explains that after talking to a patient named Elise, she realized she does want kids one day, but helping Lizzie feels just as important to her. Their bond is complicated but strong, even with all the uncertainty.

Meanwhile, Dr. Frost is facing ghosts of his own. Ainsley, the actress that played his mother when he was a child actor, someone he once saw as a protector but whose relationship with him crossed lines he wasn’t ready for. Frost finally opens up to Dr. Charles, admitting that what he once thought was love was really fear and confusion. Ainsley tries to convince him it was mutual, but Frost knows now that it wasn’t okay. It’s an uncomfortable, messy realization, but it’s the start of reclaiming a piece of himself he’s kept buried for a long time.

The episode closes with a mixture of hope and unresolved wounds. Clarissa survives. Max starts his new life with the Andersons. Matt is awake and recovering. Sharon and Dennis reaffirm their future together after some honest conversations. Naomi promises Lenox she’ll prove herself. And Dr. Frost finally starts to look at his past honestly, not the story he told himself, but the truth he needed to face.

It wasn’t just about saving patients this week. It was about saving yourself,  even if the hardest part is just admitting the hurt is there.

What do you think?

Change Image

• Loved it
• Hated it
• So/So