Ryan Coogler's Sinners (2025) Film Review

Black Panther director Ryan Coogler steps into the world of horror with Sinners and as both a horror enthusiast and a fan of Mr. Coogler’s work, this was easily one of my most anticipated films of the year. After catching it in theaters over opening weekend, I’m thrilled to share my (spoiler free) thoughts because this one absolutely delivered.

Here's my Ryan Coogler, Sinners 2025 review....

Right out of the gate from the opening sequence, it's clear that Coogler made the right move in crafting an original story rather than relying on existing IP (Black Panther) or true events (Fruitvale Station). Coogler stated Sinners is deeply personal and it is evident through the film. Sinners showcases his artistic vision in a way we haven’t seen before in the best possible way. The production design is phenomenal, immersing us in the 1930s Deep South with incredible attention to detail. The period setting is brought to life through authentic set pieces and striking costume design (teaming up with Oscar winner Ruth E. Carter again), both of which elevate the film’s power. I also appreciated the use of practical effects over CGI as it transports the audience to Mississippi offering a realism that seems lost in other films.

Cinematographer Autumn Durald Arkapaw (her second collaboration with Coogler) delivers her finest work to date. The cinematography is breathtaking and you can tell how each frame was carefully constructed to enhance both atmosphere and storytelling. Kudos to Arkapaw who helped solidify Coogler as a gifted filmmaker.

The film’s music, composed by another frequent collaborator of Coogler's, Ludwig Göransson, is another standout element. One particularly memorable scene involves the main character playing guitar, which moves between musical styles across cultures and eras. It’s a powerful moment that cements Göransson as one of today’s most versatile and exciting composers. This score easily ranks among his best and that is saying something.

The cast is packed with talent. Michael B. Jordan is excellent in dual roles as the twin brothers Stacks and Smoke, while Jack O’Connell shines as a sinister villain but ends up being funny in his own unique way. As I said, music plays a big part in this film and O'Connell offers something to chew on in that respect for the viewer as well. Hailee Steinfeld delivers her best performance since True Grit, and the supporting cast, Wunmi Mosaku, Jayme Lawson, Delroy Lindo, and Li Jun Li are all terrific. However, the true breakout is newcomer Miles Caton, who centers the film with an unforgettable debut performance. He brings a quiet intensity to the protagonist that makes his journey captivating from beginning to end from his first line to his last.

What I loved most about Sinners is its unique blend of genres. Vampires, Southern Gothic atmosphere, African-American history and culture, it’s all woven into an epic, genre-bending story. At times, the film reminded me of From Dusk Till Dawn (a comparison being used heavily, but its true) and, interestingly enough, even Shaun of the Dead in the way it combines horror with character and tone.

As far as location, while much of the action takes place in a single area, a juke joint the twins plan to open, the film never feels confined. This is all thanks to the world Coogler has crafted brilliantly.

If I had one critique, it’s that the film could’ve been trimmed slightly. There were a few scenes that dragged a bit, and tighter editing in those moments might have made the pacing a little sharper. That said, I was never bored, and the overall flow of the story keeps you engaged.

Sinners is Ryan Coogler’s most ambitious and artistically satisfying film to date. It feels like his “blank check” movie, an original, passionate, and genre-blending story that’s unafraid to take risks. From the stellar cast to the incredible visuals, ghostly score, and immersive worldbuilding, this is a film that not only entertains but leaves a lasting impression.

If you haven’t seen Sinners yet, I highly recommend checking it out and forming your own opinion. And if you have let’s talk! I’d love to hear your thoughts. Drop a comment down below.

Rating: 5/5 stars | 10/10